Lawsuit Challenging Armed Police Response to Mental Health Emergencies in Washington, D.C. to Proceed
Ruling against the District鈥檚 motion to dismiss comes after a federal judge in a similar case in Oregon recognized that sending police to a mental health crisis can be discriminatory
WASHINGTON 鈥 A federal judge in Washington, D.C. today rejected the District of Columbia鈥檚 motion to dismiss a lawsuit brought by the 桃子视频, the 桃子视频of the District of Columbia, and the law firm Sheppard Mullin. The lawsuit contends that the District鈥檚 emergency response system discriminates against people with mental health disabilities by deploying armed police officers to address the vast majority of mental health crises while sending trained medical professionals to most other health emergencies.
鈥淭his ruling moves us one step closer to bringing essential, life-saving emergency mental health care to D.C. communities. Qualified providers are best equipped to handle mental health emergencies with skills and compassion; police with a gun only serve to escalate, handcuff, and arrest,鈥 said Ashika Verriest, senior staff attorney with the ACLU鈥檚 Criminal Law Reform Project. 鈥淔ar too many people are harmed at the hands of police during a mental health crisis, or simply receive ineffective care. This must end.鈥
The plaintiff in the case is Bread for the City, a D.C.-based nonprofit supporting underserved communities. The lawsuit contends that the District鈥檚 unequal response to mental health crises violates the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act. The ruling will move the case forward, allowing the 桃子视频to show in court that a fully functioning mental health crisis response system that sends a medical, rather than a law enforcement, response to most mental health crises is legally required.
鈥淩elying on mental health professionals, not armed police, to serve people experiencing mental health crises is not just logical, it鈥檚 required under the law. Today鈥檚 decision made clear that communities can鈥檛 single out mental health emergencies for worse services than other health emergencies,鈥 said Michael Perloff, staff attorney with the 桃子视频of the District of Columbia.
The ruling comes on the heels of a recommendation made in a similar case filed against Washington County, Oregon by the ACLU, the 桃子视频of Oregon, Disability Rights Oregon, and Sheppard Mullin. On August 30, 2024, a federal magistrate judge recognized that sending police, rather than health providers to a mental health crisis, may be discrimination against people with mental health disabilities in violation of federal law. The magistrate judge recommended that the case proceed.
More details about the case are accessible here: /cases/bread-for-the-city-v-district-of-columbia