Challenging Death Qualification and the Death Penalty in Kansas (Kansas v. Fielder)
What's at Stake
Every person accused of a crime is entitled to a jury of their peers that represents a fair cross section of their community. But that is never the reality for Black and brown people facing the death penalty. A process called death qualification excludes people from capital juries if they do not believe in the death penalty. Death qualification rigs juries to be whiter and more likely to convict. It discriminates against Black prospective jurors, women, and people of individual faiths that oppose capital punishment.
Our fight against death qualification is just one piece of our upcoming challenge to Kansas’ use of the death penalty. The ACLU, together with the law firms Hogan Lovells and Ali & Lockwood, Democracy Forward, and the Kansas State Board of Indigents’ Defense Services’ Death Penalty Defense Unit is putting the death penalty on trial in Kansas in a series of hearings beginning in October.
Summary
Death qualification is discriminatory. Echoing a long history of racial bias in the criminal legal system, the practice dictates that to serve on a capital jury, a prospective juror must be willing to impose the death penalty. Those who are unwilling cannot serve. Death qualification disproportionately excludes Black people, women, and those of religious faith, who are all groups more likely to oppose the death penalty.
By systemically barring Black community members from fully participating in jury service, death qualification violates the rights of both the accused and the prospective jurors alike. The removal of Black voices from capital juries unjustly skews juries to be whiter, less likely to consider all of the evidence, and more prone to conviction, perpetuating the legacy of all-white juries that have historically condemned Black individuals to death.
In Kansas, there is an undeniable line connecting the state’s violent struggles over slavery and history of racial terror to its modern administration of the death penalty. When lynching became less publicly and politically acceptable, new forms of racialized violence emerged, including police brutality and the death penalty. As was the case with lynching, the death penalty in Kansas is applied disproportionately against Black men, especially when a white woman is the victim. The longstanding harm and racial violence inflicted on Black Kansans has left deep distrust in the criminal legal system, including skepticism of and opposition to the death penalty.
Since Black Kansans are more likely to disagree with capital punishment, they are disproportionately excluded from serving on capital juries. Without representation on juries, the racist cycle continues: death qualification leads to the exclusion of Black jurors and whitewashed juries that disproportionately sentence Black people to death, which prompts further distrust in the racist system. Ending death qualification is a step towards overcoming this shameful history of exclusion and injustice.
Death qualification is just one piece of the failed death penalty in Kansas that we are challenging. Every aspect of the death penalty, from who gets charged, to who has a fair trial, and to who gets sentenced is infected with racial discrimination. Beyond racial discrimination, the death penalty in Kansas is flawed in a myriad of unconstitutional ways. It fails to protect the innocent, costs taxpayers far more than the alternative, and does not deter crime.
For these reasons, the Ƶand its partners are putting the death penalty on trial in Wyandotte County, Kansas. In a series of hearings beginning on October 28, we will present evidence demonstrating that the death penalty in Kansas is unconstitutional and that death qualification is racially discriminatory and undermines the principles at the core of our legal system.
Legal Documents
-
Motion Challenging Capital Punishment in Kansas as Unconstitutional Under State and Federal Constitutions -
Motion Challenging Death Qualification as Unconstitutional Under State and Federal Constitutions -
-
Exhibit A - Mona Lynch Expert Report: Death Qualification in Sedgwick County -
Exhibit B - Wanda Foglia Expert Report -
Exhibit C - Scott Sundby Expert Report -
Exhibit D - Elisabeth Semel Expert Report -
Exhibit E - Shawn Leigh Alexander Expert Report: A Brief History of Race Relations in Kansas -
Exhibit F - Jeffrey Fagan Expert Report: Capital Punishment and Deterrence -
Exhibit G - Charles Epp Expert Report: People's Perceptions of Interactions with the Kansas City, Kansas Police -
Exhibit H - Frank Baumgartner Expert Report: Homicides, Capital Prosecutions, and Death Sentences in Kansas -
Exhibit I - Tricia Bushnell Expert Report -
Exhibit J - Jeffrey Fagan Expert Report -
Exhibit K - Brent Campney Expert Report: Racist and Police Violence Against Black Kansans -
Exhibit L - Carol Steiker Expert Report -
Exhibit M - Frank Baumgarnter Expert Report: Media Coverage of Sedgwick County Capital Prosecutions -
Exhibit N - Frank Baumgarnter Expert Report: Cost of the Death Penalty in Kansas
Exhibit A - Mona Lynch Expert Report: Death Qualification in Sedgwick CountyCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit B - Wanda Foglia Expert ReportCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit C - Scott Sundby Expert ReportCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit D - Elisabeth Semel Expert ReportCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit E - Shawn Leigh Alexander Expert Report: A Brief History of Race Relations in KansasCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit F - Jeffrey Fagan Expert Report: Capital Punishment and DeterrenceCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit G - Charles Epp Expert Report: People's Perceptions of Interactions with the Kansas City, Kansas PoliceCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit H - Frank Baumgartner Expert Report: Homicides, Capital Prosecutions, and Death Sentences in KansasCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit I - Tricia Bushnell Expert ReportCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit J - Jeffrey Fagan Expert ReportCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit K - Brent Campney Expert Report: Racist and Police Violence Against Black KansansCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit L - Carol Steiker Expert ReportCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit M - Frank Baumgarnter Expert Report: Media Coverage of Sedgwick County Capital ProsecutionsCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Exhibit N - Frank Baumgarnter Expert Report: Cost of the Death Penalty in KansasCourt: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
-
Court: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Court: Kansas State District Court
Affiliate: Kansas
Press Releases
Ƶand Partners Challenge Death Qualification and the Death Penalty in Kansas